The Psychology of Self-Respect: why men stay quiet when they are hurt, from Denver men's therapist Bryce Giron Mathern
| |

The Psychology of Self-Respect: Why Men Stay Quiet When They’re Hurt

It is often hard to call people out on their disrespectful behavior. We have been conditioned to be easy-going and not get upset when someone makes us feel small or bad. I want to talk about the importance of taking care of ourselves and honoring our dignity in relationship. We don’t have to explain to others why we deserve respect. We deserve it because we are human beings. This is about standing up for ourselves, not through pleading, but through clear, direct boundaries.

You don’t take yourself seriously. You don’t hold people accountable. You apologize for setting boundaries.
Nedra Glover Tawwab, on why people don’t respect your boundaries

Each time, you face a choice: protect your self-respect or protect the other person’s comfort.
Relationship Psychology Substack

How Men Lose Self-Respect in Small Moments

It often happens in simple moments. Someone says something hurtful. Then they laugh as if you should laugh with them. Maybe the person who said it can see that something is wrong, but they want to move on rather than face their impact. You are faced with a choice in that moment. Do you stand up for yourself, or do you go along with things and act like what hurt wasn’t a big deal?

I’m going to say that most of us have been taught not to rock the boat. Smile through the hurt, maybe tease back a little, but never acknowledge the pain you’re feeling inside. Naming that hurt is not culturally acceptable. Women are often shamed as being too dramatic for saying something: “Oh my God, you make such a big deal about everything.” Men who say something are branded as weak: “Don’t get so upset, I was just kidding.”

These little hurts can build up over time into much bigger hurts, because they start to create an internal narrative that we are not worthy of taking care of ourselves. That our self-worth is not enough to say no to someone else’s shitty behavior.

You can’t let this happen.

Getting Trapped in Vulnerability Stuffing

It sucks when people say hurtful things. We may feel tightness in our chest, our jaw or some other part of us. We may feel tension on the side of our head. This is a signal from our unconscious that what just happened is not okay. If we really pay attention, we may even feel the impulse to stand up for ourselves.

Closely after that comes something that denies that impulse.

Often we think that if we sulk, act upset or show some kind of annoyance toward the person, they will get it. They may ask what is wrong, but we are stuck in a place between directly stating our hurt and pushing our vulnerability deep down inside of us.

So we choose the path of least resistance. We say nothing.

People rarely read our minds, or have the capacity to hold themselves accountable for something that hurt us. As they watch us squirm with discomfort, they are feeling some discomfort too, and hoping that nothing gets said. It is also vulnerable to be called out for hurtful behavior, regardless of intention.

So you have two people, who may really care for each other, struggling to communicate about a small act that may now become a division in their relationship for hours, days, maybe weeks. If it is left unsaid, the pain continues regardless of how it gets rationalized. This is one of the most common patterns I see in couples counseling.

Man sitting alone on a windowsill, quietly holding in a hurt instead of speaking up

Speaking Our Truth

What is so hard about not saying anything? Why does it feel so bad that we didn’t call someone out for saying something that hurt our feelings? We often know they didn’t mean it the way we are experiencing it. We may know that this person really cares for us. We can use all of this to rationalize our way out of a messy situation.

What gets lost is our sense of self-respect. We are overriding ourselves. The thing that was said is the simple part. The real pain is not having the courage to stand up for ourselves.

When we do speak our truth, we feel relief. Maybe not right away, but eventually our nervous system responds with an “atta boy.” When we stop dismissing our feelings, we start to retrain our nervous system to no longer overrule us. We are saying, “No, I’m worth saying that this is not okay.”

Speaking our truth doesn’t have to explain why we deserve to be treated respectfully. It is direct and clear: “That hurt my feelings. Don’t say things like that anymore.”

I recall a moment several years ago when I was traveling with my family. I was teasing my brother about his commitment to going to bed early. I told him he was acting like an old man and being dumb. As he got up to go to sleep, he looked at me and said, “Don’t make fun of me for going to bed early anymore.” Then he went to bed. I have never teased him for going to bed early again. When he said it, I felt his respect for himself and his expression of truth.

This is how we stop allowing people to mistreat us. It doesn’t have to be dramatic or full of justification. We just say, “Here is my truth. Respect it.”

I don’t know many people who are good at this. If we want to create healthy, nourishing relationships, we all need to do it better. It isn’t the other person’s responsibility to notice anything. It is our job to take care of ourselves. We have to commit to our own self-respect, and to living our values out loud.

How This Shows Up in My Life

I would like to say that I’m really great at this, and that I often stand up for myself and keep clear boundaries with the people I love. That is not what usually happens. Usually I shut down and rationalize the other person’s actions.

“They were just kidding.”
“I don’t need to take this so personally.”
“It’s not that big of a deal.”

One of my core wounds is not feeling like people are going to care for my feelings. I rarely anticipate that someone can hold what I need to say to them. Instead, I anticipate the reactivity, the defensiveness, the dismissal of what I’m about to say.

In that anticipation, I shrink away. I feel the hurt in my body and regulate on my own. Nothing is expressed. I have been doing this for years. I actually feel like a fraud writing this post.

I’m mostly afraid of the emotional abandonment I often felt as a child. What I needed was someone to tell me it was okay to feel hurt, sad or frustrated. That rarely happened, and as a result I have a younger part inside me that says, “Don’t say anything.”

But in acknowledging my limitation, I see an edge for growth. I can see where I have not stood up for myself consistently and owned my self-respect. So I begin again, each day, with the intention to speak my truth when I’m hurt, dismissed or met with aggression. I set the intention to hold boundaries with those who unknowingly, and sometimes knowingly, hurt me.

I hope we can all get better at caring for ourselves.

Ready to Start Speaking Up?

If you recognize yourself here, you don’t have to work on it alone. I offer men’s counseling in Denver and telehealth across Colorado, plus relationship coaching for men and an online men’s group that meets every two weeks to practice exactly this: expressing your needs and communicating in a way your partner can hear. You can also hear more conversations like this on the BrassBalls TenderHeart podcast. When you’re ready, start with a free 30 minute phone consultation.

Wishing you the day you need to have!


References:

Tawwab, Nedra Glover (2021). Set Boundaries, Find Peace: A Guide to Reclaiming Yourself. TarcherPerigee, New York, NY.

Similar Posts